D&D 11: What are we going to do about theatre & the performing arts?
Feminist criticism / reviews of theatre and performing arts - is it useful? - What would you contribute?
Wendy Thomson - 11 January 2016
REPORT DETAILThose Who Took Part
Wendy Thomson - Female Arts magazine (called the session)
Laura Kressly - The Plays The Thing UK
Gina Smith - Female Arts
We discussed what is a ‘feminist’ review and what is a ‘feminist’ show?
We had to define feminism, those attending agreed this to be (the pursuit of) gender equality.
Bechdel Testing Theatre in Reviews
Would it be helpful to include a Yes / No in reviews which stated if a performance passed the Bechdel test? (see @BechdelTheatre) Responses varied - some said it might be beneficial to the reader (as beneficial as a star rating) but because of the flaws with the Bechdel test (which was created for films) one-women shows for example would always fail the test.*
So it was agreed that it would not be helpful for a review to rate ‘How feminist was the show’? Also a review should not feminist shame.
Critics recording gender split / ethnicity split in productions
Laura Kressly talked about her experiences as a reviewer (Everything Theatre, Remote Goat) and as a critic for her own performing arts review platform ‘The Plays The Thing UK’ she had started to record the gender split of the cast in shows and also the ethnicity split. We discussed if it was possible to implement this at Female Arts.com and the disadvantages which include the difficulty to record this data about the creative team, who are equally relevant to a production.
Who are feminists?
Vivian Ezugha asked if feminist reviews should and can involve men as well as women? (consensus was yes) and we discussed feminist criticism from third world countries, and not just female perspective, we discussed ‘female’ and the fluidty of gender and trans.
Subconscious prejudice in critics
Oluwatoyin Odonsi asked if reviewers consciously try to strip out their prejudices when they review? There can be and there is class, race, lgbtq and regional bias in reviews / reviewers and there can be very different responses from critics to the same show - perhaps due to their experiences / backgrounds.
We discussed the importance of diversity in critics and if this is reflected in mainstream publications e.g. The Guardian (Lyn Gardner, Michael Billington).
Oluwatoyin asked if there is training for theatre critics - Female Arts have reviewer guidelines / manual and we may hold training workshops in future. Laura Kressly recommended the book ‘How to Write about Theatre’ by Mark Fisher and The Guardian's courses.
This D&D session was very helpful to us at Female Arts.com, the leading online publication for female artists and creatives. We are seeking more reviewers (from anywhere in the UK) and we're aiming to hold workshops / training on reviewing from a feminist perspective.
* EDIT: Bechdel Testing Theatre kindly gave some feedback after the report was published: Sorry to have missed this discussion! 1 woman shows pass if 2 female characters played/relayed by 1 actor… though personally I prefer 2 women on stage because a) to see a relationship alive & b) more parts for us! star rating is a good analogy for #BechdelTesting - an indicator, but you'd want to read the whole review.
I'd love to see more in-depth feminist analysis in theatre reviews but of course that's opinions, not data… in film #BechdelTest as a start point has put #feminism & #genderrepresentation higher up reviewers agenda … & made people notice (if not yet change) underrepresentation in terms of numbers, & related issues (pay!) let's aim for both intelligent feminist reviews/analysis/debate & a greater number of parts for #WomenOnStage
ADD A NEW COMMENT
Photos from: "5 Things to avoid in an Arts Festival" and "What are the 5 reasons an Arts Festival should exist?"
10 March 20160 Read in full
9 January 20150 Read in full
4 November 20130 Read in full
25 January 20154 Read in full
27 March 20140 Read in full
6 August 20170 Read in full
11 November 20150 Read in full
4 March 20141 Read in full
How do we create platforms for work that reflects African heritage and diasporic experience without conforming to media stereotypes or venue requirements?
27 February 20143 Read in full
10 January 20160 Read in full
OTHER REPORTS FOR THIS EVENT
10 January 20167 Read in full
9 January 20160 Read in full
Working with technology within creative theatre practice - what's happening and how can we support each other? Where next for this work?
9 January 20161 Read in full
How can we be helping people with disabilities/conditions break into theatre & the performing arts/make access easier?
11 January 20160 Read in full
11 January 20161 Read in full
11 January 20160 Read in full
Click here to download a single PDF of this D&D sessionDOWNLOAD REPORT
ADD A REPORT
Add a report of a session you participated in at the D&DADD A REPORT
JOIN THE SITE
Join the site to be part of the D&D community, write reports, comment, book tickets and create an invitationSIGN UP